Scarlett Hampton's stepbrother, Jay Romero, interrupts Maria Anjel and Scarlett Hampton, who are dressed alike, while they are setting up for a St. Patrick's Day celebration. About their shirts, which said "Ask Me, I Might," he inquires. He might be able to flaunt their adorable tits with their shamrock pasties, Scarlett teases him. However, Maria and Scarlett seek to persuade Jay that he must indulge in Scarlett's stepfamily sex fetish before they will let him see the goodies. The girls turn around and give Jay a booty shake to make him feel better before telling him to put his dick through something so his mother can catch him. The family fetish is being discovered. Jay declines, but later on they discover him eating cereal with his hardon in it. With Scarlett's hand on Jay's cock, they phone Jay's mother and allow her to catch them. Scarlett tells Jay that he had best fuck her quickly before she rushes out to get Scarlett's dad. The girls start off by giving Jay a double blowjob as a reward for his cooperation. Then, as Jay fucks her in the doggy and Scarlett massages down her best friend's snatch, she gets to finally indulge her familial sex obsession. When Maria scoots forward on her back and takes the D between her thighs, she gets a shot at him. With Scarlett cradling her, she truly indulges herself. She maintains her hotness while riding Jay's fuck stick in a cowgirl pose. When Jay pulls out to cover Scarlett in his come, she squeals with delight. Scarlett gets on her back for him to do her one last time. In the midst of the girls' confection, Scarlett and Jay's parents arrive home.