Because Nathan Bronson is grounded, he must spend New Year's Eve hanging out with his stepsister Paige Owens and her friend Lily Larimar. The girls make the decision to get in Nathan's face by stripping off and donning party hats. Nathan is instructed to tidy up, but to begin with the party hats. He wants to move on to Paige's breasts after starting with Lily's. Lily informs Paige that she owes Nathan for being mean, which makes Paige stress out. Lily chooses to assist Nathan as payback for Paige's rudeness after Paige is embarrassed to see that he has a boner. Lily pulls Nathan's penis out and gives it a minute before announcing that she is drenched. Nathan quickly accepts her invitation as she reclines on the couch and pushes her thong aside. Paige tries not to notice her friend's stepbrother eating her pussy, but she kind of wants to join in. She begins to sulk as she slides her hand inside her panties. After a while, Lily becomes aware of it and asks Paige to test Nathan's tongue out. Paige agrees, as it's just her stepbrother. Paige is curious about her stepbrother's abilities after witnessing Nathan's mouth through Lily's tongue playing with her titties. To get Nathan's dick moist in Lily's and Paige's snatch, the girls bend down on their knees and set up a pussy buffet. Lily lays Nathan down on the couch and gets on board for a rough and tumble ride while Paige sucks her nipples to the point of extreme sensitivity. After that, Paige moves to the couch to make room for Nathan to drive deeply. Nathan lets out a moaning climax and then slides out to coat her snatch in jizz.