With Aria Alexander, Logan Pierce is playing a game of "I'll show you mine if you show me yours" when Aria's stepsister Jessa Rhodes joins in on the fun. The blonde claims that she believed she was Logan's favorite and is instantly furious. Intrigued, she undoes Aria's underwear and makes Logan decide which vagina he prefers. Logan gets to work selecting his option after realizing he can't decide without trying both pussies. He begins with simultaneous finger fucking the two girls, but soon the rivalry between them intensifies into a contest to discover who can deliver the best blowjob. Before he realizes it, Logan has provoked the two stepsisters into a passionate threesome. As they sort out their sibling rivalry in the sexiest way possible, the sisters alternate between letting him fuck their eager tiny pussies and eating each other out. Logan soon finds himself in his own climax, all over Jessa and Aria's seductive faces. Logan finds himself having to make the decision of who has the better pussy as they enjoy the afterglow.