Jay Romero, Maria Kenzie's stepbrother, is in the breakfast nook, where she is preparing a sandwich in the kitchen. Since the stepsiblings don't usually get along, Jay chooses to start a fight when Maria is about to eat. When she wonders what's wrong, he tells her that she's just gross after eating. She notices the expression on his face. Jay continues by saying that he believes she also makes repulsive noises when she fucks. Jay storms out of the room after Maria tells him that he's just envious that she's having an affair with his friend. Later, Jay is wondering about his stepsister while pounding his meat. He calls her name out loud when he cums, and Maria hears it and storms in. When Jay is faced with his attractive stepsister, he gets an idea. He tells her that it's unfair that she can hear his sex noises but he can't hear hers. He informs Maria that he must hear her sex noises in order to be fair. Maria considers it and then gives her approval. Just as Jay asked, she masturbates, pulling her shirt down to see her titties and then taking off her shorts to slide her underwear aside. When Maria begs her stepbrother to fuck her soaking wet pussy, Jay is eager to comply because her foul words simply makes him angrier. To ensure that Jay is as hard as a rock only for her, Maria starts them off by sucking him off. Maria turns around and lets Jay lead the way inside while palming his ass. She jerks backwards to meet him thrust for thrust because she is so eager. Jay's back is flipped, allowing Maria to climb up and give her stepbrother a bald pussy stiffie ride, first in cowgirl mode and then in reverse. When they're done, they lay with Maria on her back, spreading her legs wide with their hands on her calves. Jay is glad to oblige, rewarding his attractive stepsister with a large cream pie.